The Government’s proposed NBN reforms won’t correct fundamental structural problems within Australia’s broadband and telecommunications industry, according to Dr Michael Porter, Director of CEDA Research. [Research and Policy article]
In a submission to the federal government's discussion paper, National Broadband Network: Regulatory Reform for 21st Century Broadband, Dr Porter argues that the number one priority for the Government is to make the structure as pro-competitive as possible and then to implement a suitable regulatory framework to manage any remaining monopoly related competition issues.
"In a sense, the Government's Discussion Paper is putting the regulatory cart before the structural horse," Dr Porter said.
The submission comments on:
The submission proposes a strategy based around:
Dr Porter suggests that the competitive tension would be created through the separation of copper and fibre optic networks form HFC cable assets.
Telstra and other carriers, in exchange for equity, would be invited to fold copper and fibre assets into a new integrated Australian network.
This network could be partly funded through Government loans and incentives to meet backhaul and black spots demands.
This company would then compete with end user suppliers such as the newly created independent cable corporation and existing wireless providers.
"What Australia needs now is not an expensive public sector rollout and regulatory expansion, but the facilitation of the potential that literally lurks beneath the surface and in the skies," Dr Porter said.
"To spend up to $43 billion of community resources on an NBN defies sound economics in an era as challenging as the once faced in 2009. The Government should not improve its economics by limiting competition; particularly in view of its plan to sell the NBN back to the private sector in five years time."
The alternative structural model outlined in the submission would create a more secure wholesale environment and increased competition among end-user providers, resulting in better service and choice for Australian consumers.
To read the full submission click here.
Australia’s digital competitiveness significantly improved in the last 12 months – rising six places in a ranking of the digital competitiveness of 63 countries released today. Australia recorded the second largest year-on-year improvement in the rankings, behind only Croatia.
Read more Technology | Innovation September 28, 2021Australia slipped to 20 in the IMD World Digital Competitiveness Ranking (WDCR) with its key weaknesses being business agility along with digital skills and training.
Read more Technology | Innovation October 30, 2009Global innovation experts analyse the weaknesses of Australia's innovation system, the potential of IT and telecommunications and the future for industries such as biotechnology. [Research and Policy article - Full content is only available to CEDA members]
Read moreMake a donation today to directly support CEDA’s independent research, tackling the big issues for Australia. Click here.
(Donations over $2 are tax deductible)